The pay question
How to answer “what are your salary expectations?” in a screen: ask for the band, then give a range anchored to the role and the market, starting at the figure you want, and leave current pay out of it.
What it is
The pay question is any version of “what are your salary expectations?” or “what are you looking for in terms of compensation?” that arrives before an offer. It's a negotiation move dressed as a logistics question: the first number on the table tends to become the reference point for everything after it. Harvard's Program on Negotiation describes this anchoring effect and notes that a wage or wage range cited by the employer tends to anchor talks in the employer's favor, while naming what you earned at your last job introduces a low anchor, since most people are trying to improve on it.
In places with a salary-history ban, the question is also the lawful replacement for “what do you make now?”. New York State is one example: the state's official guidance explains that since January 6, 2020, Labor Law Section 194-a bars an employer from asking an applicant about current or past pay, or relying on it to decide whom to interview or what to offer, and adds that the employer may ask about the applicant's salary expectations for the position instead. So when a recruiter there asks what you're looking for, they may be asking the one version of the question the law still allows.
| Part of a good answer | What it sounds like | Why it helps |
|---|---|---|
Ask for the band | “Is there a range budgeted for this role?” | Their number anchors the talk, and under the EU directive applicants are entitled to the starting pay or its range before the interview. |
Give a range, with a floor | “I'm looking at 120 to 135.” | In Ames and Mason's studies, a modest range drew better counteroffers than a single figure. |
Anchor it to something | “That's where senior engineers in Denver sit on the public wage data and in the postings I've seen.” | Shows the figure came from the role and the market, not from a wish. |
Stay open | “I'm flexible on the mix of base, bonus and equity.” | Signals you can be talked to without lowering the floor. |
Leave current pay out | Talk about this role's value, not your last paycheck. | Your past salary is a low anchor, and in places with a ban the employer may not ask for it. |
Why a range beats a single number. Columbia Business School's Daniel Ames and Malia Mason tested point offers against ranges in salary and other bargaining tasks, and reported in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 2015 that modest ranges produced better deals. The best-performing shape was what they call a bolstering range: start at the figure you actually want and stretch upward, so a candidate who wants 70 asks for 70 to 75. A bracketing range centered on the target (68 to 72) helped less. The researchers also found limits: a range that reads as unreasonable can backfire, and ranges that worked best kept their two ends within about 20% of each other. Counterparts did not rate range-makers as pushier; those who received a bracketed range rated the other side as less aggressive. The practical reading for a screen: your floor is the number you want, not the lowest you'd tolerate, and the top sits a modest step above it.
Where the research comes from. Three sources, in order of how specific they are to your case. First, the posting and others like it: pay bands published for comparable roles at the same company or its competitors. Second, in the EU, the employer itself: under the pay transparency rules the European Commission described as taking effect in June 2026, employers have to give job seekers the starting pay or its range, either in the job ad or before the interview, and may no longer ask about pay history. Third, government statistics: the US Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes wages for over 800 occupations at the national, state and metropolitan level. Those figures are broad, covering an occupation rather than a level or an employer, so treat them as a check on the private salary sites rather than as the floor itself. Bring the figure to the call already worked out, so the answer is a sentence and not a pause.
When to use it
Use this shape when the question comes from a person before an offer: a recruiter call or a first conversation with the hiring team. If a form asks for one figure and gives you no way to ask for the band, the same preparation still applies: enter the floor of your researched range, the figure you want. Our advice: have the answer ready before the first conversation rather than hoping the question waits for the offer.
It also applies when the question arrives sideways: “what's your current salary?”, “what did you make at your last job?” or an “optional” current-pay box on a form. Under New York's rules an employer may not pose even an optional salary-history question, and an applicant who refuses to answer is protected from retaliation. Our advice wherever you are: redirect to what you're looking for, which is the information that helps them place you anyway.
When not to
The full shape is for the case where you don't know the band and they do. Some cases call for less.
- The band is in the posting. Asking for it again suggests you didn't read it. Say where in the band you expect to sit and why: “The posting shows 110 to 140; given my years at this level I'd expect the upper half.”
- Pay is set by a scale. Where a published grade or a collective agreement sets the pay for the role, there is little range left to negotiate. Ask which grade or step the role sits on and what moves you up one.
- You don't know the level yet. If the same posting could be mid or senior, one range covering both is wide and commits you to its floor at either level. Either give a separate range for each level, or give the reason and a plan: which conversation will settle the level and when you'll send a number.
- Your current pay is above the band. The rule against naming it exists because it usually anchors you low. When it would anchor you high, volunteering it can help: New York's law permits an applicant to disclose salary history unprompted, for instance to justify a higher figure, and the employer may then take it into account. The key word is unprompted.
- You're at the offer stage. Once a written offer exists, the question is no longer “what are you looking for” but “what would make you say yes”, and the answer is a counter on the actual numbers. The screen-stage range has done its job.
Compared
| Answer | What it signals | When it's the right call | Where it goes wrong |
|---|---|---|---|
Ask for the band before answering | You know the number is theirs to share first | Whenever you don't know the band, and anywhere the rules require the employer to share a range before the interview | Asking twice after they've declined, or asking when the band is already in the posting |
A researched range with a floor | You've done the work and can still move | They won't share a band and you know the level; floor is the figure you want, top within about 20% | A range so wide it says nothing, or a floor set at the least you'd tolerate |
A single number | Certainty | The posting shows the band and you're placing yourself in it, or a form field accepts one figure | Point offers drew lower counteroffers than modest ranges in the research, and a single figure shows less flexibility than a range does |
A reason to wait, plus a plan | You're careful, not evasive | The level or the mix of base, bonus and equity isn't known yet | Waiting with no plan reads as a dodge, and leaves the recruiter with nothing to work from |
Your current pay | Your last employer's budget | Unprompted, when it sits above this role's band and the law where you are lets them use what you volunteer | Anchors low in the common case, and hands over information that, where a ban applies, the employer isn't allowed to ask for |
In a picture
How to say it in an interview
The common mistake
Quiz
Related
Sources
- Salary History Ban: What You Need To Know (New York State)
- New EU rules on pay transparency explained (European Commission)
- Overview of BLS Wage Data by Area and Occupation (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics)
- Offering a Range of Numbers Can Lead to an Edge in Negotiations (Association for Psychological Science)
- Compensation Negotiation Tips for Salary Bargaining (Program on Negotiation, Harvard Law School)