Skip to content

Answering a hypothetical

A “what would you do if…” question asks how you'd handle a case you haven't met. The interviewer is judging your reasoning: what you'd find out, the options you'd weigh, your first step, and how you'd know it worked.

On this page

What it is

A hypothetical is a question about a situation you haven't been in: “What would you do if…”, “How would you handle…”, “Imagine that…”. Google's re:Work guide to structured interviewing treats it as one of the two kinds of structured question, next to the behavioral kind, and says interviewers use it to see how a candidate copes with something new, judging the thinking rather than looking for one correct answer. The Association of American Medical Colleges' guide to structured residency interviews calls the same thing a situational question, and says it rests on the premise that what a person intends to do predicts what they will do. The format goes back to work by Latham, Saari, Pursell and Campion in 1980.

The interviewer may have follow-ups ready. Structured hypotheticals often come with prepared probes. The AAMC's list for situational questions includes what you'd do first, what you'd say, what factors would affect your course of action, what other actions you could take, how your action would be received, and what you'd do if it wasn't received well. Google's sample question comes with follow-ups on the factors you'd weigh, the pros and cons of your recommendation, and how you'd judge whether it was working. Since the scenario is handed to you, most of your answer is what you'd do and what would come of it. Both guides also recommend scoring against a rating scale, ideally with each point anchored by an example of what that level of answer looks like, so a rater can match your answer to a described level. Our advice: build the answers to those probes into your first pass, so the follow-ups go deeper instead of filling gaps.

PartWhat you sayWhy it helps

Clarify or assume

One question whose answer would change your approach, or the assumption you're making instead.

Shows you understood the problem before solving it, and makes the rest of your answer checkable.

The factors

The constraints, people and numbers that would shape the choice.

Lets the interviewer see what you'd weigh, which is what the planned probes ask about.

Two ways

At least two approaches, and the cost of each.

A single approach reads as a reflex; two show judgment.

Your pick and first step

Which one you'd choose, why, and the first concrete thing you'd do.

A plain first step is the easiest thing for a listener to follow and compare.

Who you'd involve

The people you'd talk to or bring along.

Shows the choice happens with others, not in your head.

How you'd know

A sign or a measure, with a time frame.

Closes the loop. Without it the answer is a plan with no test.

A good hypothetical often holds a dilemma. Latham's group argued that a situational question should force a choice between two courses of action that both look desirable, so a candidate is less able to score by saying the pleasing thing. Huffcutt and colleagues note this in their 2004 meta-analysis of the two formats, and also observe that many of the questions in the studies they reviewed had no obvious dilemma, so expect one without counting on it. An example from the AAMC's residency guide: on morning rounds, a senior colleague praises your handling of a hard case in front of the team and gives you all the credit, leaving out the peer who did much of the work. What would you do? Staying quiet keeps the moment smooth; correcting the record is honest but costs something. Our reading: the honest move is the floor, and what lifts an answer is how you'd make it, whether in the moment or in private afterwards, what you'd say to the peer, and why you'd choose that way.

When to use it

Use this shape when the question puts you in a case rather than asking for one from your past: “What would you do if a customer…”, “How would you handle a teammate who…”, “Imagine you join and find…”. Northeastern University's career office suggests the same moves for these questions: ask a clarifying question if you need one, think aloud so your reasoning is visible, consider more than one approach before settling, and explain the trade-offs in the choice. It also notes that these questions often have no single right answer, which is why the reasoning is what gets compared.

If you're asked what you'd do in your first month in the role, treat it as a hypothetical about a job you don't have yet. Say what you'd learn first and from whom, name one early result you'd aim for, and say how you'd check that it landed. That is our advice on shape; the content has to come from what you've learned about the team.

When a real case fits, use it as evidence, not as the answer. Give the approach first, then one or two sentences on the time you did something close and what came of it. The meta-analysis by Huffcutt and colleagues found that hypothetical questions predicted performance less well for high-complexity jobs, while past-behavior questions were not affected by job complexity. Our inference: for a senior role, a real example beside your plan carries weight that a plan without one doesn't.

When not to

  • The question asks for a past event. “Tell me about a time…” wants what you actually did. Tell it as a story (The STAR method); the imagined options can wait until a follow-up asks what you'd do differently. Structured interviewing guides separate the two kinds: behavioral questions are there to reveal patterns in what you've done.
  • It's a narrow probe. “What's the first thing you'd do?” wants one step and its reason, in two or three sentences. Rebuilding the whole shape spends the time set aside for depth.
  • There's no one to ask. In a recorded one-way interview or an automated screen, a clarifying question gets no answer. State the assumption you're making in one sentence and go on.
  • The scenario is already fully specified. A question the interviewer has already answered sounds like stalling. Ask the one question that would change your approach, or none.
  • A direct question with a short answer. “Would you report it?” wants yes or no in your first words, then the reason (Answer first).

Compared

The choiceOption AOption BA is right whenB is right when

Opening

Ask one clarifying question

State an assumption and go

A live interviewer is there and the answer would change your approach

It's recorded, the scenario is already specific, or you've used your one question

Breadth

Two approaches, each with its cost

One approach

The question is open or holds a dilemma

It's a narrow probe such as “what would you do first?”, or the clock is nearly out

Evidence

Add a real past case

Stay in the hypothetical

You have a close match you can tell in two sentences

Your case is far from the scenario, or the interviewer said to imagine you've not done this before

An unknown rule

Say what you'd check and who you'd ask

Decide on the spot

You don't know the policy, or the rule is the point of the question

The scenario gives you the rule, or says the situation must be handled this minute

The measure

A number with a time frame

A qualitative sign

The outcome is countable: late tickets, wait time, defects

The outcome is about trust or morale, where a sign (people come to you earlier) is more honest than an invented number

In a picture

The scenarioAsk or assumeWhat mattersTwo ways, costedPick, first stepWho you involveHow you'd knowTheirfollow-ups
The shape of a first pass at a hypothetical. The follow-ups then go deeper on whichever part the interviewer wants to probe.

How to say it in an interview

The common mistake

Quiz

In a recorded one-way interview, the scenario leaves out a detail that would change your approach. What do you do?
A hypothetical puts you in a procurement review, and a vendor offers you event tickets. What separates a satisfactory answer from a stronger one?
“What would you do if two deadlines collided?” You have a real case that matches. How do you use it?
Which closing line best answers “how would you know it worked?”

Related

Sources

  1. A guide to structured interviewing for better hiring practices (Google re:Work)
  2. Developing Structured Residency and Fellowship Interviews: Content and Evaluation Related Components (AAMC)
  3. Interview Type: Behavioral and Situational (Northeastern University Employer Engagement and Career Design)
  4. The Impact of Job Complexity and Study Design on Situational and Behavior Description Interview Validity (Huffcutt, Conway, Roth and Klehe, preprint of International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 2004)
Sign in to report a mistake