Disagree with a teammate
The first sections are free. The sample answer, follow-up questions and quiz are part of Pro.
On this page
What it tests
Whether you can disagree with someone you work with and still reach a good decision together. Who was right matters less than how you got there. Expect to be asked for both positions stated fairly, what you did to understand the other side, how the call got made, and whether you two still worked well afterward. Amazon writes this into a leadership principle: challenge a decision respectfully when you disagree, then commit to it fully once it is made.
What the interviewer listens for
| What | Why it matters |
|---|---|
Situation | The project, what was at stake, and the two positions, in a sentence or two. Without stakes, a disagreement sounds like a quarrel over taste, and the interviewer cannot judge whether how you handled it fit the size of the problem. |
Task | Your role in the decision: did you own it, own one side of it, or need the other person’s work to finish yours? That tells the interviewer whether you were deciding, persuading or asking for help. |
Action | The center of the answer. The steps you took: how you asked about their view, what you checked, how you set up the conversation, what you proposed. “We talked it through” gives the interviewer nothing to note down. |
Ownership | Both pronouns have a job here. Amazon’s interview guide asks for “I” when you describe your own part, while one interviewer who writes about asking this kind of question hopes to hear mostly “we” and treats “us and them” talk as a red flag. Both fit: say “I” for the steps you took, and “we” for the decision and the work you shared. |
Decision | What was decided and why that option won. This is where “we compromised” goes wrong: a compromise can be the right call, but the interviewer needs to hear what each side gave up and why that split served the work. |
Trade-off | What the chosen path cost. If your view lost, say what you accepted. If it won, say what the other person’s concern was protecting and how you covered that risk. |
Result | Two results: what happened to the work, and what happened between you and your teammate. The question is about working together, so the relationship is part of the outcome. |
Learning | One thing you do differently in the next disagreement, such as asking what the other person is protecting before you argue, or agreeing on a test before debating. A concrete habit beats a general lesson about communication. |
Specifics | One real disagreement on one project, with real details. “I always try to see both sides” is a claim about yourself; the interviewer has to judge an example. |
Numbers | Optional. A number helps when data settled the question, such as a test result or a deadline you met. Do not reach for one when the outcome was really about trust between two people. |
How to structure the answer
| Part | What to say |
|---|---|
Situation | The project, the stakes and the two positions, in one or two sentences. State the other person’s view the way they would state it. |
Task | Your part in the decision: the owner, one side of it, or someone whose work depended on it. One sentence. |
Action | Most of your time. How you learned why they held their view, what you checked, how the decision got made, and what you did once it was made. |
Result | What shipped or changed, and how the working relationship came out. |
Learning | One habit you kept or changed for the next disagreement. |
Pitfalls
| Pitfall | Why it hurts |
|---|---|
Making the other person the villain. | A story where the other side had no good reason shows little listening or weighing, and those are what this question is about. The interviewer is also hearing how you will one day describe a teammate at their company. Give the other view its strongest form, including what it got right. |
Saying “we compromised” without explaining the decision. | It hides the part being judged. The interviewer cannot tell what was decided, who gave up what, or whether the split was good for the work or only ended the argument. |
Picking a disagreement with nothing at stake. | If either choice would have been fine, the story shows little judgment. Pick a case where both options had a real cost. |
Ending with “and they came around.” | A story where the other person simply gives in may show persuasion, but not that you listened. If you did change their mind, also say what they raised that changed yours, even a little. |
Settling it by going over their head. | Escalation is sometimes right, but as a first move it can suggest the two of you did not try to work it out, and one interviewer who asks this question lists settling it by rank or escalation as a red flag. If you escalated, say why talking first did not work and that you raised it together. |
Concepts this guide uses
Sources
- Your complete guide to the Amazon interview process
- 6 common mistakes candidates make during their Amazon job interview, and tips to avoid them
- Amazon Leadership Principles
- A guide to structured interviewing for better hiring practices (Google re:Work)
- Unpacking Interview Questions: Tell Me About a Disagreement (Jacob Kaplan-Moss)
- Using the STAR method for your next behavioral interview (MIT Career Advising and Professional Development)